Woman smiling at another woman while holding pen

A Beginner’s Guide to Captive Health Insurance

01/16/2024 Written by: AP Captives

Are you new to the world of health insurance and wondering what captive plans have to offer? You’re in the right place! In this beginner’s guide, we’ll break down the basics of employee benefits captives to help you understand how it works and whether it might be the right choice for your organization.

What is Captive Health Insurance?

Captive health insurance is a unique and specialized form of self-insurance. It involves a group of companies, often from the same industry or with similar risk profiles, coming together to create their own insurance company, known as a “captive.” This captive insurer is exclusively dedicated to covering the health insurance needs of the member companies and their employees.

How Does Captive Health Insurance Work?

  • Formation of a Captive: Several companies with similar risk profiles decide to form a captive insurer that operates as a separate legal entity.
  • Risk Pooling: Member companies contribute funds to the captive insurer. These funds are pooled to cover health insurance claims of the employees from the participating companies.
  • Customized Policies:Captive health insurance allows member companies to tailor insurance policies to their needs. This flexibility often leads to more cost-effective coverage.
  • Risk Mitigation: The member companies share the risk, which can lead to potential cost savings. In good years with low claims, surplus funds may be returned to the member companies. In years with high claims, the program remains stable.
  • Regulation and Compliance: Captive insurers are subject to regulatory oversight and must adhere to laws governing the insurance industry in their respective jurisdictions.

Benefits of Captive Health Insurance

  • Cost Control: Companies can better control insurance costs by customizing policies to fit their unique needs and risk profiles.
  • Financial Incentives: Surplus funds may be returned to member companies during profitable periods.
  • Tailored Coverage: The ability to create customized policies means that companies can offer more tailored benefits to their employees.

Challenges of Captive Health Insurance

  • Initial Setup Costs: Creating and managing a captive can be costly and may require insurance and risk management expertise.
  • Regulatory Compliance: Captive insurers must navigate complex regulations and may need to meet stringent capital requirements.
  • Limited Risk Pool: The success of captive insurance depends on the financial stability of the member companies. A downturn in one member company can affect the entire captive.

Is Captive Health Insurance Right for You?

Whether captive health insurance is a good fit for your organization depends on various factors, including your company’s size, risk profile, and financial stability. It used to be that small to medium-sized businesses often find value in traditional group health insurance, while larger companies with stable finances may explore captive options.

Captive health insurance offers an alternative approach to managing health insurance costs. It’s a sophisticated strategy that can provide cost savings and tailored coverage, but it also comes with its complexities and regulatory requirements.

To help more companies take advantage of alternative insurance solutions, our captives team developed APLUS – a program specific to organizations with as few as 25 employees.

If you’re considering captive insurance, our team can help you decide if it’s the right choice for your organization.


November Captives Blog
Alternative Risk Considerations
Captives11/09/2023

Alternative insurance programs can be a powerful tool for businesses to manage risk effectively and potentially save costs on property and casualty coverage for a company. “Challenges in the current...

October Captives Blog
AP Captives: Teamwork for Claims Success
Captives10/26/2023

Claims are a significant cost to any operation, and captives are no exception. However, an important benefit of captive membership is the control organizations can maintain over their claims-handling...

Captives Blog
Risk Scores Impact Employee Benefit Costs
Captives09/20/2023

Over the past several years, we’ve seen unprecedented medical inflation, causing many employers to ask how to control benefit costs and increase productivity. After exhausting the supply side of...